The Great Debate: Mac vs. PC
So which should you buy? I Will once and for all not settle this debate, however I think I can give some direction to allow you to buy what is right for you. I use both a Mac and a PC (Windows) computer on a daily basis and have some definite opions. In fact I teach in a room that is equiped with 20 MacPros and 4 PC's. My lab is Mac based because that is the industry standard and my students need to learn how to use them. My first computer was a Mac Plus back in the mid 90's. I also started using a PC for graphics in the mid 90's. I say this only so you can get an idea where I am coming from.
OK, down to the "nitty gritty", which should you buy? It depends. I know that sounds like I am side stepping the question but I am not. Both have most of the same software available and are good operating systems as long as we are talking about the most recent. Windows 7 is a great operating system that I think has made the two more closely related. I would say that the main drawback to a PC is that they are more likely to get a virus than a Mac because the viruses are being written for the PC. Can a Mac get a virus? Yes but it is rare because people are not writing them for Macs. Good anti-virus software and common sense can even this out so that it should not be a major consideration.
So what about the software. Well if you really like using iDVD, iPhoto, Garage Band and other Mac software then get a Mac. Those programs are great for someone that wants to use their creative juices to make movies and music. They are very capable programs I know professionals that use them for some work. However they are consumer level programs that are limited if you are looking for doing more. There are also many programs available for the PC that will accomplish the same tasks, but I will say that Apple has some of the best consumer level software available. Once you get into the professional level of software, Adobe products, Final Cut, Pro Tools, and others, it comes down to budget and preference. Both platforms are good.
Hardware is the last determining factor. Apple at one time offered the best built computers you could buy. Saddly I think that this is no longer the case. They are still great computers but I have seen a decline in quality and that is disappointing. This opinion is not from hearing others horror stories, but from my own experience of running a lab that is outfitted with MacPro Towers. They are good but not necessarily better. Becuase there are more manufacturers of PC's they come in all flavors and quality. It makes it easier to buy for you need and not spend more than necessary. I think that this gives the PC world a leg up on Apple. I like Apple computers and products but I have a hard time uncatagorically reccommending them for everyone.
So to boil all fo this down to which is better. I would say neither. Your needs will dictate which one you should buy. If you are looking for an easy to use out of the box and know nothing about computers I sugguest looking at what Apple has to offer. The entry point is higher but your fustration level will be lower. If you are an experienced computer user and are looking to get the most bang for your buck I would look are buying a PC that meets your needs. There are more options and you can get what you need for a price you can afford. I am also a big fan of Open Source software and there is more available for the PC.
So you may want to know what I personally own? I own PC's. Two of my kids in college both use HP laptops, I use a Sony Vaio, and the "Family" computer (aka Internet Appliance) is an older E-Machine. I also do use a MacBook Pro for some work. Whatever you choose just make sure that you research you choice and make an informed purchase.